Dimiceli was a four-time letter-winner for Judson University Softball and ranks among the all-time greats within the program. She made an impact immediately as a freshman, batting .436 with 20 doubles, 71 hits, and 21 walks, all top-10 marks in single-season program history. That effort earned her CCAC 1st Team All-Conference honors and an NCCAA All-American selection. In 2009, she repeated her conference top-team honors and NCCAA All-America recognitions. In 2010, Dimiceli set three single-season program records with 14 home runs, 78 total hits, and 68 RBI. Her 14 doubles that season is also a top-5 mark. Once again, she earned CCAC and NCCAA honors. Her senior season is her most decorated as she earned CoSIDA Academic-All American honors, CCAC first-team All-Conference, and was an NCCAA All-American selection. Additionally, she was named the 2011 Judson's Athlete of the Year and the 2011 Scholar-Athlete of the Year. She is first in program history in hits (284), RBI (209), and runs scored (176). She is second in program history in doubles (62), home runs (37), and batting average (.418).