McHenry was a part of the beginning of the modern success of Judson baseball as he was a member of the 2012 baseball team that made Judson’s first NAIA postseason in that decade and only the second appearance ever. During that run, he led the team in numerous categories. He had 83 hits (third all-time single-season), 52 RBI (ninth all-time), 21 doubles (third), nine home runs (ninth), 221 at-bats (eighth), and he was third in the team in runs scored with 47. He was named the Judson Male Athlete of the Year as well as being named CCAC First-Team All-Conference. During his freshman year (2009) he tied the single-season record with seven triples. In 2010, he was an all-conference player as he hit .347 with 59 hits in 170 at-bats.