All nominees must meet the following criteria to be considered for selection:
-
Have been out of college at least 10 years.
-
Have lettered or coached in a varsity sport at least two years at Judson College.
-
Have made an outstanding contribution to the stature of the College Athletic program and to the ideals of community life at Judson College.
-
May be selected as an Honorary member if the individual does not meet the above criteria.
In addition, all nominees must meet at least one of the following criteria:
-
All-Conference in a sport
-
An All-American (first team, second team or honorable mention)
-
A member of the United States Olympic team
-
A world champion in any sport
-
A national or world record holder
-
A national champion in any sport
-
Has made an outstanding contribution to the stature of the Judson College Athletic program
- A Judson College Athlete of the Year